WonderMill | The Official Website of the World's Best Grain Mills
Become a Dealer   Dealer Login
Homemade Peanut Butter Recipe
~Personally made with the help of your Wonder Junior Grain Mill~

Making fresh, high quality, great tasting Homemade Peanut Butter with your Wonder Junior Grain Mill is simple and fun. It's also a healthy alternative to the high sugar and preservative, stale tasting, store bought peanut butters. Once you experience fresh nut butters you'll never pick up a bottle at the store again.

Homemade Peanut Butter Ingredients

Its as easy as 123. . .

First things first:
A good hand mill is an investment and in the end will save you money, provide you with better tasting ingredients, and give you assurance in troubled times. Obviously, we suggest the Wonder Junior Deluxe that comes with Stainless Steel Burrs as well as Stone Milling Heads.

Fresh ingredients:
When making nut butters you will have fantastic results if you use fresh ingredients.

Start with these ingredients to make 3 cups of peanut butter with this homemade peanut butter recipe:

  • 4 cups of fresh shelled roasted peanuts
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 1/3 cup of canola oil
  • 1 teaspoon salt

Hand mills with high quality stainless steel burrs like those on the Wonder Junior Deluxe, make excellent nut butters, however, the nuts must be FRESH. If even slightly stale, the nuts will grind into more of a flour than a butter. This is a good way of telling if the nuts you have purchased are fresh. If the nuts you grind do not produce a smooth, consistent butter, then purchase fresher nuts.

Peanut Paste

Set your stainless steel burrs to a fine setting by adjusting the milling heads so that they are close, but not so tight that it is hard to turn the mill. When milling nuts you should have a smooth paste coming from the mill. Once you finish the grinding simply add salt, sugar, and canola oil to get the desired taste and consistency. Stir to peanut butter consistency and it will keep in the fridge for up to 2 months


Clean up, with a good quality hand mill, is easy. The Wonder Junior Deluxe is completely washable and the heads are easily removed for quick clean up in your kitchen sink. A little warm water and a few drops of dish soap and your done.

Don't forget, with the Wonder Junior you can make many kinds of nut butters, ranging from Almond and Cashew butter to Sesame butter. Let your imagination run wild and enjoy this homemade peanut butter recipe.

Your Own Peanut Butter